Zoom Salon - Wuthering Heights (1939) – 106 minutes | Mechanics' Institute

You are here

Zoom Salon - Wuthering Heights (1939) – 106 minutes
April 2021 CinemaLit: Wonderful William Wyler

Friday, April 23, 2021 - 6:00pm

CinemaLit Film Series

April 2021 – Wonderful William Wyler

The Academy Awards are handed out on April 25 this year, and now seems like the right moment to pay tribute to William Wyler. With twelve nominations and three wins, he remains the most honored director in Academy history.

We are highlighting five Wyler films, each a nominee for Best Picture and for acting categories, with one capturing the Best Picture, Director, Actor, and Supporting Actor honors: the multiple Oscar winning The Best Years of Our Lives (1946), Dodsworth (1936), Dead End (1937), Wuthering Heights (1939), and The Little Foxes (1941).

Born in Alsace-Lorraine in 1902, young Wyler soon proved himself unfit for the family haberdashery business. His mother arranged for her rebellious son to meet Carl Laemmle, her talent-scouting cousin and founder of Universal Pictures. Eventually, Wyler moved to Southern California and the Universal lot, where he began as a production assistant. Laemmle spotted his potential right away, and Wyler was directing by age 23. His silent film forte was Westerns, but sound liberated him artistically, and soon he flourished in dramas, comedies, and romances. From there, it was straight up for Wyler and into the pantheon of Hollywood's all-time greatest directors.

Wyler's output of classics is unmatched, and the urge to recite lists and hyperbolize is irresistible. The following are a few of his titles not featured in this month's tribute. Classic film buffs will recognize the magnitude of excellence here: These Three, Come and Get It, Jezebel, The Letter, Mrs. Miniver, The Memphis Belle, The Heiress, Detective Story, Roman Holiday, Friendly Persuasion, The Big Country, Ben-Hur, The Collector, and Funny Girl.

What made Wyler so good? The short answer is he was a perfectionist, and kept a close eye on every aspect of production. He was a subtle master, not prone to lavish directorial trickery. His gifts for storytelling, visual compositions, pacing, and dramatic conflict were superb. He knew to surround himself with the best in the business – producer Samuel Goldwyn, cinematographer Gregg Toland, and editor Daniel Mandell, among others.

Above all, Wyler was an actor's director. He directed many of the biggest stars for several decades, from Humphrey Bogart and Bette Davis to Gary Cooper, Kirk Douglas, Audrey Hepburn, and Barbra Streisand. He was known for multiple takes, following each with a simple, "Let's do it again." He would not readily articulate his wishes, allowing the actors to grow in their roles using their own creative powers. If his method drove them crazy ("Why don't you tell me when I'm good?" was the typical query on a Wyler set), there is no arguing the results. Wyler directed a never surpassed thirty-six Oscar nominated performances, with fourteen of them winning.

Actors spoke reverently of "Willie," grateful for the performances he drew out of them. And, like many great artists, he could be wry and plainspoken. Keep it simple, he believed. He was asked about the secret of his phenomenal success. "I have a theory," he replied. "Not to bore the audience. That's a good theory."


April 23 – Wuthering Heights (1939) – 106 minutes

Emily Brontë's 1847 gothic novel Wuthering Heights tells the familiar story of Heathcliff, the young urchin who grows up as a stable hand on the Yorkshire moors. He and Cathy, the lady of the house, fall in love, but she's conflicted by social propriety and a fear of their passion. This sets in motion years of alternating cruelty, joy, revenge, disillusionment, and – in the film if not the novel - ultimate transfiguration.

Screenwriters Ben Hecht and Charles MacArthur performed major surgery on Brontë's love story, excising whole portions of her novel. They held to her spirit with ardent dialog. Says a breathless Cathy: "Heathcliff, make the world stop right here. Make everything stop and stand still and never move again. Make the moors never change, and you and I never change."

There were multiple stress fractures in the production. Producer Samuel Goldwyn wanted Merle Oberon for Cathy, but Laurence Olivier, who was hired as Heathcliff at Wyler's suggestion, wanted then little known British actress Vivien Leigh. (Olivier and Leigh were in the midst of an affair, and would be married in 1940.) Goldwyn prevailed, but perhaps he wished he hadn't – Olivier and Oberon detested one another. In appeasement, Wyler suggested Leigh for the second female lead Isabella, but Geraldine Fitzgerald won the part. The stage-trained screen neophyte Olivier brought a disdain for filmmaking to the set. Wyler taught and trained him in screen acting, and in the process they grew to respect each other's talent. There were still contentions during production. Goldwyn and Wyler clashed over the ending. Goldwyn got his way, inserting a final shot that forever displeased Wyler.

All those cross-purposes seemed to have served the film well. It was a career high spot for everyone involved. Wyler, Olivier, Fitzgerald, composer Alfred Newman, Hecht and MacArthur were all Oscar nominated, with Gregg Toland winning for his plush black-and-white cinematography. Wuthering Heights might well have won Best Picture had not Gone with the Wind (need I say it stars Vivien Leigh?) come along to smoke the competition.


Matthew Kennedy, CinemaLit’s curator, has written biographies of Marie Dressler, Joan Blondell, and Edmund Goulding. His book Roadshow! The Fall of Film Musicals in the 1960s, was the basis of a film series on Turner Classic Movies. 

I don't have a favorite film,” Matthew says. "I find that my relationships to films, actors, genres, and directors change as I change over the years. Some don't hold up. Some look more profound, as though I've caught up with their artistry. I feel that way about Garbo, Cary Grant, director John Cassavetes, and others."

Classic films have historical context, something only time can provide,” Matt observes. “They become these great cultural artifacts, so revealing of tastes, attitudes, and assumptions.”



First watch the selected film on Kanopy. All you will need is either a Mechanics' Institute library card, or a San Francisco Public Library card, which will give you access to Kanopy and its treasure trove of movies. Make a reservation for our CinemaLit Salon as usual via Eventbrite and watch the film on Kanopy at your leisure. You will receive a link to the Friday night CinemaLit salon on Zoom one day in advance, and then an additional reminder roughly two hours in advance. On the night of the salon click the Zoom link and join us.

If you do not receive a Zoom Link by 4:00 PM on the day of the event, contact Pam Troy at [email protected]


Mechanics’ Institute members can now sign up for FREE access to Kanopy, a wonderful film streaming service. To sign up:

1. Click on  THIS LINK.

2. Click on the large orange login button that reads, “Log in to milibrary.”

3. Enter the 14-digit bar code from your MI Library card

4. Set up your account following Kanopy’s instructions, including your email and a password.

5. Kanopy will send verification to your email address.

You’ll be able to choose from a wonderful selection of films, including classics, pre-code, foreign films, and documentaries, including the films we’ve scheduled this month for CinemaLit.

If you are not a Mechanics’ Institute member, consider membership and click  HERE  to join online:

Or, you can check with your public library to see if they are Kanopy members. If so, you may use your public library card to set up a Kanopy account.


Register with Eventbrite below.

If the green TICKET button is not immediately visible, scroll down on the right in the Eventbrite window until it appears.


CinemaLit Films

Members Free
Public Sliding Scale Free to $10
Register now ›
Pam Troy - 415-393-0116
Register now by using the form below or calling .

Future CinemaLit Films

Apr 30 - 6:00pm

Zoom Salon - The Little Foxes (1941) – 117 minutes
April 2021 CinemaLit: Wonderful William Wyler

May 7 - 6:00pm

Zoom Salon - The Seventh Seal (1957) – 98 minutes
May 2021 CinemaLit: Visions of the Sacred on Film

May 14 - 6:00pm

Zoom Salon - Whale Rider (2002) – 102 minutes
May 2021 CinemaLit: Visions of the Sacred on Film

May 21 - 6:00pm

Zoom Salon - Leona (2019) – 95 minutes
May 2021 CinemaLit: Visions of the Sacred on Film

May 28 - 6:00pm

Zoom Salon - Legend of the Mountain (1979) – 193 minutes
May 2021 CinemaLit: Visions of the Sacred on Film

Jun 4 - 6:00pm

Dream State: California in the Movies, with author Mick LaSalle, a Zoom salon
A CinemaLit Author Event, cosponsored by Heyday Books